Evidence Insight
pdf-extract-experimental-materials
91100Total Score
Core Capability
83 / 100
Functional Suitability
11 / 12
Reliability
10 / 12
Performance & Context
8 / 8
Agent Usability
13 / 16
Human Usability
7 / 8
Security
9 / 12
Maintainability
9 / 12
Agent-Specific
16 / 20
Medical Task
20 / 20 Passed
100You need to build a structured inventory of reagents/antibodies/consumables from a paper's *Materials and Methods* section
4/4
97A document includes a Key Resources Table and you want to convert it into clean CSV outputs
4/4
95Accepts PDF-derived Markdown/text as primary input; falls back to PDF text extraction when needed
4/4
94Table-first parsing: prioritizes structured tables (e.g., Key Resources Table) before scanning prose sections
4/4
94End-to-end case for Accepts PDF-derived Markdown/text as primary input; falls back to PDF text extraction when needed
4/4
Veto GatesRequired pass for any deployment consideration
Skill Veto✓ All 4 gates passed
✓
Operational Stability
System remains stable across varied inputs and edge cases
PASS✓
Structural Consistency
Output structure conforms to expected skill contract format
PASS✓
Result Determinism
Equivalent inputs produce semantically equivalent outputs
PASS✓
System Security
No prompt injection, data leakage, or unsafe tool use detected
PASSResearch Veto✅ PASS — Applicable
| Dimension | Result | Detail |
|---|---|---|
| Scientific Integrity | PASS | No scientific-integrity problem was surfaced in the legacy audit for the Extract experimental materials and instrument information from PDFs (or PDF-derived text/Markdown) into three CSV tables workflow. |
| Practice Boundaries | PASS | Practice boundaries held because the package remained focused on source handling, lookup, or structured evidence use. |
| Methodological Ground | PASS | The archived evaluation treated the workflow as method-linked rather than ad hoc. |
| Code Usability | PASS | Code usability passed because the package still exposed a reviewable execution surface for its documented workflow. |
Core Capability83 / 100 — 8 Categories
Functional Suitability
A modest deduction remained in functional suitability for pdf-extract-experimental-materials in the archived review.
11 / 12
92%
Reliability
The archived evaluation left some headroom for pdf-extract-experimental-materials under reliability.
10 / 12
83%
Performance & Context
No point loss was recorded for performance context in the legacy audit.
8 / 8
100%
Agent Usability
A modest deduction remained in agent usability for pdf-extract-experimental-materials in the archived review.
13 / 16
81%
Human Usability
Related legacy finding for pdf-extract-experimental-materials: Minor polish before wide rollout. No major defects found
7 / 8
88%
Security
The legacy audit deducted points for pdf-extract-experimental-materials in security.
9 / 12
75%
Maintainability
The legacy audit deducted points for pdf-extract-experimental-materials in maintainability.
9 / 12
75%
Agent-Specific
The legacy audit deducted points for pdf-extract-experimental-materials in agent specific.
16 / 20
80%
Core Capability Total83 / 100
Medical TaskExecution Average: 96 / 100 — Assertions: 20/20 Passed
100
Canonical
You need to build a structured inventory of reagents/antibodies/consumables from a paper's *Materials and Methods* section
4/4 ✓
97
Variant A
A document includes a Key Resources Table and you want to convert it into clean CSV outputs
4/4 ✓
95
Edge
Accepts PDF-derived Markdown/text as primary input; falls back to PDF text extraction when needed
4/4 ✓
94
Variant B
Table-first parsing: prioritizes structured tables (e.g., Key Resources Table) before scanning prose sections
4/4 ✓
94
Stress
End-to-end case for Accepts PDF-derived Markdown/text as primary input; falls back to PDF text extraction when needed
4/4 ✓
100
Canonical✅ Pass
You need to build a structured inventory of reagents/antibodies/consumables from a paper's *Materials and Methods* section
For You need to build a structured inventory of..., the preserved evidence is lightweight but positive: the packaged validation command behaved as expected.
Basic 38/40|Specialized 60/60|Total 100/100
✅A1The pdf-extract-experimental-materials output structure matches the documented deliverable
✅A2The script execution path completed successfully for the documented case
✅A3The output stays fully within the documented skill boundary
✅A4The response quality is acceptable for the documented path
Pass rate: 4 / 4
97
Variant A✅ Pass
A document includes a Key Resources Table and you want to convert it into clean CSV outputs
The archived run for A document includes a Key Resources Table and you want to convert... confirmed the helper entrypoint and left the workflow in a stable state.
Basic 36/40|Specialized 60/60|Total 97/100
✅A1The pdf-extract-experimental-materials output structure matches the documented deliverable
✅A2The script execution path completed successfully for the documented case
✅A3The output stays fully within the documented skill boundary
✅A4The response quality is acceptable for the documented path
Pass rate: 4 / 4
95
Edge✅ Pass
Accepts PDF-derived Markdown/text as primary input; falls back to PDF text extraction when needed
The Accepts PDF-derived Markdown/text as primary input; falls back to... path verified the packaged helper command without exposing a deeper execution issue.
Basic 35/40|Specialized 60/60|Total 95/100
✅A1The pdf-extract-experimental-materials output structure matches the documented deliverable
✅A2The script execution path completed successfully for the documented case
✅A3The output stays fully within the documented skill boundary
✅A4The response quality is acceptable for the documented path
Pass rate: 4 / 4
94
Variant B✅ Pass
Table-first parsing: prioritizes structured tables (e.g., Key Resources Table) before scanning prose sections
For Table-first parsing: prioritizes structured tables (e.g., Key..., the preserved evidence is lightweight but positive: the packaged validation command behaved as expected.
Basic 34/40|Specialized 60/60|Total 94/100
✅A1The pdf-extract-experimental-materials output structure matches the documented deliverable
✅A2The script execution path completed successfully for the documented case
✅A3The output stays fully within the documented skill boundary
✅A4The response quality is acceptable for the documented path
Pass rate: 4 / 4
94
Stress✅ Pass
End-to-end case for Accepts PDF-derived Markdown/text as primary input; falls back to PDF text extraction when needed
For End-to-end case for Accepts PDF-derived Markdown/text as primary..., the preserved evidence is lightweight but positive: the packaged validation command behaved as expected.
Basic 31/40|Specialized 60/60|Total 94/100
✅A1The pdf-extract-experimental-materials output structure matches the documented deliverable
✅A2The script execution path completed successfully for the documented case
✅A3The output stays fully within the documented skill boundary
✅A4The response quality is acceptable for the documented path
Pass rate: 4 / 4
Medical Task Total96 / 100
Key Strengths
- Primary routing is Evidence Insight with execution mode B
- Static quality score is 83/100 and dynamic average is 83.6/100
- Assertions and command execution outcomes are recorded per input for human review
- Execution verification summary: Script verification 1/1; adjustment=5. validate_skill.py: OK